Confessions of an Aussie Coin Noodler: The Mule Mystery

Confessions of an Aussie Coin Noodler: The Mule Mystery

A $1 Coin Hunt Like No Other

It was a crisp, autumn morning, the kind that whispers of possibilities as the sun breaks through the early fog. I was sipping coffee at my desk, absentmindedly flipping through a pile of pocket change I'd dumped out in front of me. There’s something satisfying about rummaging through coins, an activity steeped in nostalgia and curiosity. But today wasn’t just any ordinary coin noodling session. Today, I was after a legend.

The 2000 Australian $1 Mule Coin

I first heard about it in a forum, the numismatic equivalent of a treasure map passed around in secretive circles. The story behind the mule was irresistible. It was a fluke, a mistake where a $1 coin was accidentally minted with the obverse (head) of a 10c coin. This misstep led to one of the rarest and most sought-after coins in Australian history. With only a handful of them in existence, each mule could fetch thousands of dollars. For a coin enthusiast like me, this wasn’t just a collector’s dream. This was my white whale.

The Search Begins

With newfound determination, I started methodically checking every $1 coin that passed through my hands. I scoured second-hand stores, picked up coin rolls from the bank, and even found myself asking for $1 coins as change whenever possible. Every time I cracked open a new roll, that tiny voice in the back of my mind whispered, Could this be it?

Days turned into weeks, and the mule coin continued to elude me. Yet, the hunt had become an obsession, and not just for me. I’d drag my friends into it, giving them quick lessons on how to spot the mule—“Look at the queen’s head! It’s slightly smaller than usual. The rim’s thicker!”—before sending them off to noodle through their own change piles.

The Twist of Fate

I was at a local market, browsing through the usual knick-knacks, when I wandered into a cluttered stall with a haphazard collection of old currency. Coins from all over the world were piled high in old biscuit tins, waiting for a curious hand to sift through them. Without thinking, I reached in. The cold metal of the coins clinked together as I dug through, half expecting to find nothing more than a few worn pennies and weathered shillings. But then something caught my eye.

It was a $1 coin, slightly off in its appearance. The queen's head, while familiar, was oddly small. My pulse quickened. Could it be? I pulled out my loupe, my hands trembling as I scrutinized every detail. The thickness of the rim, the alignment of the design—it all matched. This was no ordinary $1 coin. This was it. The mule.

The Heart-Pounding Moment

My heart raced as I handed over a few crumpled notes to the vendor. They had no idea what they were selling, and I wasn’t about to enlighten them. I walked away with what felt like a winning lottery ticket clutched in my hand. The world seemed to slow down as I processed the gravity of what had just happened. I’d done it. I’d found the Australian 2000 $1 mule coin.

But here's the twist—just as I was about to leave the market, a tall man with a battered leather jacket approached me. He glanced down at the coin in my hand, his eyes widening slightly. "That," he said, his voice low, "isn't something you find every day."

My mind raced. Was he a fellow collector? A dealer? Worse—was he after the mule too? Before I could respond, he pulled out a business card and handed it to me. “Let’s just say…if you’re looking to part with it, I’ll make sure it finds a good home.”

And just like that, he disappeared into the crowd.

The Decision

I stood there, staring at the card. The thrill of the hunt had been incredible, but now I had an unexpected decision to make. Do I keep this rare treasure, a symbol of perseverance and luck? Or do I entertain the idea of selling it, cashing in on the years of searching for this one-in-a-million find?

The card was still warm in my hand as I slipped it into my pocket, my mind racing with possibilities. I knew one thing for sure: the mule coin had changed the game for me, and this was far from the end of my numismatic adventure.

And as for what I’ll do next? Well, that’s a story for another day.

Pt 6 Now Live!

Back to blog